Seriously, what's the deal with remakes? Whatever happened to originality? "Mostly Martha", "Abre los ojos", "The Lives of Others", the list goes on and on.
I like all three of these actors, but I really don't get why there has to be a remake of a perfectly fine film which was only just released 2/3 years ago...

madchen that's the same thing with martin scorcese making a remake of an hong kong film that was ony released three years ago. martin's remake: the departed. hollywood is running dry with ideas so they have to come see what the europeans and asians are doing and then make remakes of the great films they see over there and hollywood-a-fy their remakes.

it really is getting boring and redundant. also why is that jake is the black-sheep of the family. if anything tobey looks like he could be the black-sheep of any family. ouch! okay that was mean.

I don't mind remakes as long as they're interesting and maybe add a new dimension to the original movie. There are only so many stories out there to be told; what you can do is add new details.

I think The Departed is a bit better than Infernal Affairs so that's a remake I don't mind. And this remake I think could totally be worth watching as well. Having seen Brothers I must say that Jake is more suitable to play the black-sheep brother, his part is really cute in the movie (while the other brother isn't very sympathetic, he's kinda creepy).

Wow, that photo of Natalie Portman literally made me gasp. She looks stunning.

Ugh, this is a terrible idea. The original Danish film is brilliant and incredibly moving and was only released about 3 years ago for gods sake! Why do they have to remake it? Are they seriously that low on ideas? And I really don't think they can improve upon the original at all or bring anything fresh to it because the original was already fresh and (for lack of a better word) original. And on a sidenote, the American cast is at least 10 years younger then their Danish comparatives. Again with the youth obsession.

there have always been remakes around even in the 20s when film was so young. anyway, this looks good simply because of the cast: the plot doesn't sound nearly as promising.