Quantcast
 

Is It Hard to Get Into Music That's Not in Your Own Language?

Wed, 08/27/2008 - 6:30am by BuzzSugar
520 Views - 41 comments

I'm a fan of the Icelandic band Sigur Rós, and have especially enjoyed their newest album, Með suð í eyrum við spilum endalaust. But as much as I like them, they don't tend to get as much iPod love from me as other artists do, and I think it might be because I don't understand the lyrics to a lot of their songs (did you know the Icelandic language is a North Germanic language descended from Old Norse? I love Wikipedia).

On the other hand, I'm not an English-or-nothing kind of woman by any means. There are non-English Bjork songs I dig, and the delicate songs on Yael Naim's album that are in French and Hebrew are fantastic, for example.

What do you think? Is it more difficult to get into a band when you don't understand what they're singing about?

Source

on Yahoo!

41 Comments Add a Comment

  • foreignative's picture
    foreignative
    1

    if you're trying to learn a new language i highly recommend listening to music in it. it really helped me learn German (thanks Die Aerzte, Fettes Brot, Die Fantastischen Vier). Each time you listen to a song you understand a new line, and it makes you really feel like you're making progress!

    13 weeks 5 days ago Report Comment
  • Shadowcat14's picture
    Shadowcat14
    2

    I would say about a quarter of my songs on my iPod are in Japanese. I enjoy watching anime with my friends and we tend to download the opening songs from our favorite shows.
    an example: "Rewrtie" by Asian Kung Fu Generation for the opening of the final season of Fullmetal Alchemist.

    13 weeks 5 days ago Report Comment
  • hil34's picture
    hil34
    3

    I listen to a lot of J-pop, and I'm fine with the language barrier

    13 weeks 5 days ago Report Comment
  • TidalWave's picture
    TidalWave
    4

    Well most of Sigur Ros' songs are not Icelandic, but are actually the lead singer's own language that he coined as "Vonlenska", which is just gibberish/scat singing.

    hil34, I love the j-pop as well!

    13 weeks 5 days ago Report Comment
  • kiwitwist's picture
    kiwitwist
    5

    It depends on the music. I love latin music and I don't have a clue what they are saying.

    13 weeks 5 days ago Report Comment
  • skigurl's picture
    skigurl
    6

    i voted yes, but when i got thinking about it, i love the song Dragonstea Din Tai, and also love a couple good French songs

    so I guess it depends, but generally i like English music

    13 weeks 5 days ago Report Comment
  • fauxtographic's picture
    fauxtographic
    8

    TidalWave - I thought the singer referred to the 'language' as "Hopelandish" or something to that effect. either way you're right, Sigur Ros is a bad example here since they're not actually singing in a defined language Smiling

    I speak / understand about 6 or 7 languages so my iPod is fairly multilingual, and I like a lot of songs well outside my language range as well - I think some music is just very universal regardless of lyrical content (though I frequently look up translations if I'm curious about what a song is about).

    13 weeks 5 days ago Report Comment
  • TidalWave's picture
    TidalWave
    9

    fauxtographic: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sigur_Rós#Vonlenska

    "Vonlenska is a term used to describe the gibberish sung by the band,[12] in particular Birgisson. It is also commonly known by the English translation of its name, Hopelandic. It takes its name from "Von", a song on Sigur Rós’s debut album Von where it was first used."

    We're both right!!

    13 weeks 5 days ago Report Comment
  • Francoisehardly's picture
    Francoisehardly
    10

    I actually know another language, that being Spanish, and besides that I recently listen to a lot of music in French which I sort of understand. I'm pretty sure I've listened to music in Japanese and probably a couple of other languages too. I'll listen to anything good.

    13 weeks 5 days ago Report Comment
  • BuzzSugar's picture
    BuzzSugar
    11

    TidalWave - oh that's funny. I probably wouldn't be able to tell Icelandic from many other languages including "Hopelandish" or "Vonlenska" Eye-wink It's still not my native language, so the example still applies. Actually, it might be the best example because it's nobody's native language!

    13 weeks 5 days ago Report Comment
  • Maribug's picture
    Maribug
    12

    I'm gonna say yes, even though most of the music I listen to isn't in my own language, seeing as Engilsh isn't my mother tongue. But I understand it, and that's what matters. However, lyrics aren't always very important, so I can like some music that I don't understand, it just doesn't happen very often. Mostly because I don't bother checking it out, I guess, because the places where I find most of my music recommendations are mainly focused on music in English (or Norwegian).

    13 weeks 5 days ago Report Comment
  • Whiplash's picture
    Whiplash
    13

    I don't put too much emphasis on lyrics in general. Of course, I can really love a great lyric or (more likely) get turned off by really stupid lyrics, but all in all, they're not as important to me as the melody, arrangement, etc.

    I listen to a lot of non-English-speaking artists. Most of them are from France or the Scandinavian countries; some artists sing in Japanese, Spanish or Dutch. As long as the song sounds nice, I don't care what language it's in.

    13 weeks 5 days ago Report Comment
  • ilanac13's picture
    ilanac13
    14

    i actually have a lot of music that's not in English and i LOVE to listen to it. one of my all time favorites is MC Solaar from France. i only understand words here and there since he's a rapper - but i LOVE LOVE LOVE to listen to him on my iPod.

    13 weeks 5 days ago Report Comment
  • Taadie's picture
    Taadie
    16

    I like a lot of Spanish music. And French and Portuguese.

    13 weeks 5 days ago Report Comment
  • Allytta's picture
    Allytta
    17

    not at all. i have songs in about 7-8 languages and i know all the lyrics to them.

    13 weeks 5 days ago Report Comment
  • Juicylemon's picture
    Juicylemon
    18

    In Quebec where most people talk french, music in english gets a lot of airplay, high sales and are in demands. Much more than music in french. Also, there the biggest summer hits can be in spanish.

    I think it's about the arrangement, the melody, the rythm and the hooks more than just the lyrics.

    13 weeks 5 days ago Report Comment
  • Megatron's picture
    Megatron
    20

    I love Yael Naim! If the music moves me, it moves me so I guess I don't have a language barrier problem.

    13 weeks 5 days ago Report Comment
  • catita85's picture
    catita85
    21

    Sure! My native language is Spanish, but I learnt English at a very young age and have no problem understanding lyrics. I also like some Brazilian artists and French ones too.

    13 weeks 5 days ago Report Comment
  • treb's picture
    treb
    22

    I think their albums are best when you listen to the entire thing and you're just chilling. I don't listen to them in the car or when I'm at work...but when I want to relax at home...and it's the entire album, not just a song here or there.

    13 weeks 5 days ago Report Comment
  • nessa17's picture
    nessa17
    23

    i listen to music in my own language
    that is spoken in africa which i like
    but other than that i dont really listen
    to music in other languages

    13 weeks 5 days ago Report Comment
  • treb's picture
    treb
    24

    Oh, and I totally make up my own lyrics to their music. I mean, I just sing the English words that sound like whatever they're actually singing.
    Do you think they have a Rosetta Stone program for "Hopelandic?"

    13 weeks 5 days ago Report Comment
  • SweetnLow's picture
    SweetnLow
    25

    I said no. I do sometimes wonder if I'm dancing around to a song about removing eyeballs and eating them (or other such nonsense) but if I am.. oh well! Sticking out tongue

    13 weeks 5 days ago Report Comment
  • cageyme's picture
    cageyme
    26

    I love listening to Nina Hagen. I know about 3 words in German, but her music and singing style is so cool that I don't care.

    13 weeks 5 days ago Report Comment
  • Frenched's picture
    Frenched
    27

    It's not really that much of a problem to me. Sometimes it's frustrating not to understand the lyrics exactly as a native speaker would BUT what attracts me to a song is usually the music. The voice can be nice, too! I'm lucky I'm bilingual because I get to listen and understand to lyrics both in English and Spanish but I also listen songs in French and other languages...and of course, I listen to Bjork's Icelandic songs, too! Karvel comes to mind Laughing out loud

    13 weeks 5 days ago Report Comment
  • amofoz's picture
    amofoz
    28

    Chritsina Sturmer is awesome but I really wish I could sing along to her songs!

    13 weeks 5 days ago Report Comment
  • jasmint's picture
    jasmint
    29

    Not at all! A good portion of the music I listen to is in French and Portuguese -- I've also got some German, Japanese, and Italian in my collection. Listening to these songs has definitely helped me pick up some vocabulary, and I've even learned several entire songs! Along with my love of foreign films, my love of foreign music has got me on my way to being multi-lingual Smiling

    13 weeks 5 days ago Report Comment
  • Mädchen's picture
    Mädchen
    30

    If you ever want to impress your friends with an "exotic" song, here's one of my favourite ones in Swiss German:
    Züri West - I schänke dr mis Härz
    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_qVADii3Ja0
    Smiling
    Also, if you ever feel like listening to some German music and need some recommendations, just ask me. Eye-wink

    13 weeks 5 days ago Report Comment
  • bastylefilegirl's picture
    bastylefilegirl
    31

    Nope...not I"m not sure if I'm going to get all Icelandic but I listen to French HipHop and my French is poor to say the least but it's still great!

    13 weeks 5 days ago Report Comment
  • bastylefilegirl's picture
    bastylefilegirl
    32

    Oh and I like Tatu as well the Russian version of there album was way better than the english version

    13 weeks 5 days ago Report Comment
  • californiagirlx7's picture
    californiagirlx7
    33

    The only albums that I listen to on an occasional basis that are in a different language are Selena's "Dreaming of You" album (some songs are in Spanish) and Celine Dion's "The French Album," otherwise known as "D'eux."

    13 weeks 5 days ago Report Comment
  • Lysa1237's picture
    Lysa1237
    34

    No, I listen to a lot of french Music .....Vanessa Paradis, Ina-ich...., Japanese rock as well....Maximum the hormone, etc...., I do not know any of the two languages but I definitely love their music

    13 weeks 5 days ago Report Comment
  • sharshar's picture
    sharshar
    35

    I love Sigur Rós even if I have no idea what their songs mean--the same goes for random artists in my library like Alex Ubago or Eros Ramazzotti. Japanese rock is addictive, too.

    13 weeks 5 days ago Report Comment
  • Advah's picture
    Advah
    36

    I don't mind when it's not a language I can understand. I think the 'problem' with Sigur Ros is just that they don't really have albums you can sing along or listen to for 5 mins then stop for 2 mins. I know I have to be in a specific context to be able to really enjoy them.

    Talking about that - I'm seeing them this weekend at the Festival! Woohoo!

    13 weeks 4 days ago Report Comment
  • Phorrest99's picture
    Phorrest99
    37

    I don't think so. When I lived in Ecuador it was really common to hear music on the radio in Portuguese or French even (aside from music in Spanish & English of course), so I've always liked listening to music in all different languages. I'm usually more into the beat anways Smiling

    13 weeks 2 days ago Report Comment
  • Witchy Ways's picture
    Witchy Ways
    38

    My mother tongue is German and generally speaking, I'd prefer german lyrics over english ones if they're done right. I just think that you can do so much more with german, it's such a complex language that it gives you many more things to play with. So I'm all for witty german songs!

    I also love swiss german rap since it's very similar to the dialect I speak.

    French rnb and rap is wonderful to listen to when studying french, it really helped me a lot.

    13 weeks 1 day ago Report Comment
  • Witchy Ways's picture
    Witchy Ways
    39

    i almost forgot:

    Peter Gabriel's german albums are the most hilarious thing I've ever heard. They're so unintentionally funny, pure genius!

    13 weeks 1 day ago Report Comment
  • JaeB's picture
    JaeB
    40

    If it sounds good, I listen to it. I also try to get a translation of the lyrics, though.

    I

    13 weeks 1 day ago Report Comment
  • JaeB's picture
    JaeB
    41

    *I love Japanese music (L'Arc~en~Ciel, T.M.Revolution!) and Bjork, and some French and Spanish music. Makes me very happy.

    13 weeks 1 day ago Report Comment

Leave a Comment

To post comments, please sign in or register.



Morsels of goodness, delivered daily.

Enter your email below: